Wednesday, March 21, 2012

Airport: A Reflection on Single Parenting

It’s getting late, about 11 p.m. on a Sunday night, a few days before Halloween. After several flight delays, I’m still at the American Airlines terminal at Chicago's O’Hare Airport, waiting to board the plane to Dallas, where I have a meeting in the early morning on the next day.

I pace around restlessly. Then I set down my fold-over carry-on bag, the strap of which is digging into my shoulder, and I wearily drop into the nearest plastic-form chair.

Sitting opposite me is a young girl, about 13, and her older brother, about 17, I would say. They’re wearing jeans and sneakers and look a bit tired and rumpled. They trade banter and tease each other affectionately. The girl is holding a plastic trick-or-treat bag that she keeps rummaging in, perhaps a gift from a grandmother. She takes out a homemade cupcake with orange icing and a chocolate jack-o-lantern face. Then a younger sibling, a sister with long brown hair, perhaps seven or eight, arrives, with their mother in tow. The girl is carrying an identical trick or treat bag. The mother is a cheerful and sophisticated-looking woman, dressed in business attire. She’s wearing a wedding ring.

For me, the frequent flyer, airports are all alike, and so are the people I see there. Yet for some reason, I find myself staring.

They don’t stare back but smile good-naturedly at me.

This scene of relaxed family togetherness seems so ordinary, yet to me so poignant. Families, it always seemed to me, are the possessors of happiness. But I wonder if they are aware of their special lot, enveloped in their cocoonlike interiors of closed doors, warm glowing lights. Their secure worlds seem all so different from those of parents like me, raising a child alone. “Families, I hate you,” Andre Gide, the French essayist and novelist, once said. But I don’t feel anger or envy as I gaze at that closely knit group, only fascination and some sadness.

Maybe I’m just tired and moody, or maybe it’s just the season, the darkening days of late October with the promise of the holidays soon to come, or maybe it’s the cupcakes, a reminder of life’s simpler pleasures. Most likely, though, it’s simply the nature of my work, of newspaper work in general. For the past five years I’ve moved six times without the prospect of ever settling down. Too often I’ve had an assignment in one place, had to leave my child in another. This time, though, I am finally in a position to choose, am in a position where my daughter and I will finally be together. Nevertheless, tonight, I find myself particularly pensive and alone.

It’s time to board. Passengers begin to line up single file at the gate. I just sit there, not wanting to wait in that long queue with that bulky canvas bag. The family across from me begins to collect their coats and carry-on luggage.

“Wait!” the 13-year-old suddenly cries out. She cannot find her pass. The teen rummages in her purse, in her pockets. Suddenly, her older brother reaches into her Halloween bag and pulls out the pass triumphantly. They all laugh.

As they begin to make their way across the terminal, the little one pipes up – her pass is also missing. “You too!” says her mother good-naturedly. There’s another bout of rummaging and together they manage to find it.

I cannot take my eyes off them, those children so rambunctious and carefree, that mother so indulgent and so patient. Perhaps I idealize, a mere observer, looking on from the other side of the fence. Yet on days when I am rushed and tired and far from any place I can call home, it seems to me that I see families everywhere, reminders of a lifestyle I have not been able to provide.

“Mom,” you mustn’t be so impatient with me,” my teen-age daughter had said to me this morning.

It saddens me to realize that the patience and joy on the face of this Dallas-bound mother is not an expression with which I have often been able to turn to my child. More often than not, mine was one of impatience and worry. If she would have misplaced her pass, I know I would have said, not without exasperation, “Find that boarding pass quickly! We'll miss the flight! Why don’t you know where you put it?”

She grew up a hurried child, without that cushion provided by a family of two parents, grandparents and siblings. She grew up in a world where I had to make our way, a world filled with appointments and sitters and deadlines and schedules, a world that did not wait.

“Let’s go,” I’d say to her when she was a toddler, “or I’ll be late.” I had to get her up early so I could get to school and work. Drowsy with sleep, she’d dawdle. “Hurry,” I would tell her. “Go eat your cereal.” “Make sure you have your scarf and mittens. Where are your mittens?”

She was often out of step in a world that moved more quickly than she did. “Late again,” the elementary school teacher would say when she arrived, more often than not still munching on a slice of peanut butter toast. “You’re always late….” The teacher would tell her. “Your homework is late.” My heart would sink those many days as I sat helplessly tied to my desk at work thinking about those carefully lettered assignments still on the kitchen table, about her trying to negotiate her way alone to school or back home, about her taking the bus to her dance lessons.

"My honey, please...." I would tell her.....  “Be careful.” "Be prepared." “Be on time,” I would say.... “The world is a serious place,” I would tell her.....

“But Mom….,” she would inevitably say, explaining about the magical new snowfall that she had to explore, about the stray cat that she had found on her way to school and had to bring back home, about the library book she had forgotten and had to return for. Despite all my worry and endless direction, she simply continued to wander on blithely through life, carefree as any child, and simply assumed that the world would love her.

And it did.

Yes, she often filled her mother with much consternation, yet she also won much approval and applause. She fascinated her teachers with her tales of her misadventures, her soaring flights of imagination, and her infectious laugh. She had walked into her school for an  interview and on the spot was given a scholarship to attend. She waltzed into a professional dance audition and was the one invited to stay. She was a spinner of cartwheels, a master of mime, a fount of insatiable curiosity, always posing her inevitable " but why?" Where, her teachers have often asked me, does all her confidence and spontaneity and joy come from? Where, I have often asked myself, does it all come from?

Yes, I would have thought that this young girl would have turned out to be cautious and careworn like her mother. ‘How,” I had often asked myself, “can I continue to provide her with all she that she needs to grow and to flourish.”

Yes, there were many times in my daughter’s life when I could not be there, and there were times when I had to keep her waiting, when I was late. When parents talk to me about letting down their kids, they tell of tantrums and tirades and tears. But she never railed or complained or made demands. When an exam made me late for her school pageant she waved to me in her cat costume from the stage. When a flight delay made me late for her graduation, she stepped out of the ordered procession of mortarboards to greet me. As I look as this Dallas-bound mother, I wonder at the constancy I demanded of my child as I tried to make our way, juggling schools and jobs and schedules

Just this morning while packing, I had spoken sharply to her. “You’re so thin,” I had said, my offhand comment couching my concern only as a criticism. “Giving me more to worry about,” I said to her.

As I sit and wait here in this airport, that gentle plaint echoes.

When I begin to think about the life that she and I had, I cannot begin to tally the toll. My school. Work. The jobs. The travel. The dislocations. The years she spent in boarding school. The demands of her growing educational opportunities. I could not begin to fathom how to balance it all. There was just too much in her life that I myself could not control. No, the circumstances for her growth have not been ideal.

She is a caring child who deserved to be doted on, who should have had a rowdy bunch of brothers and sisters, a loving father, a few aunts and uncles, perhaps, even two pairs of fond grandparents. But there was nothing I could do about that. Instead I got her a shiny red bicycle that she drove around the campus where I worked, went sledding with her at Riverside Park, signed her up for those dance lessons she so wanted to attend, promised on this trip to bring her back a pair of cowboy boots….

It’s almost midnight when I hear the final call for boarding. I see the family with their trick-or-treat bags go through the boarding gate, those denizens of an insulated world where planes can wait and children are cherished. I gather up my raincoat and luggage.

“Cupcakes,” I say to myself when I walk onto the plane. “That’s what I’ll do. When I get home. we’ll make Halloween cupcakes.”

But as our life would have it, as soon as I return, she gets another scholarship, an opportunity of a lifetime.

“But the scholarship doesn’t matter,” she said heatedly to me.

“Oh yes, it does,” I said back to her.

In a way, our life has always been like that O. Henry Christmas story, each one of us willing to sacrifice the things that mean a lot for the other, but neither one of us willing to accept that sacrifice from the other. Yes, O. Henry, the master of the unexpected ending. As I help her pack,  it occurs to me that perhaps in the end, it was simply enough to do all that one could.  Yes, as I look back on it all, I begin to realize that she has somehow always found her way; and yes, it seems to me, that despite it all, she will continue to find her way.


Yet, weeks later, that airport scene still lingers in my mind. I  mention it to a colleague, a married mother of three.

“Lord knows!” she exclaims. “That woman must have been on valium! And those kids,: she adds, "they must have been on their best behavior. At home, I’ll bet you that they’re constantly at each other’s throats.” “Besides," she continues, “Maybe they weren’t even her kids. For all you know, they might have been her stepkids whom she sees once a year. Or maybe they were kids from her first marriage, living with her ex.

I consider all the possibilities. I want to believe her. But somehow I cannot.

   

15 comments:

  1. I have not been to Chicago.However every place conjures up associations.What I associate with Chicago is Chicago's first three LPs with tracks like Saturday In the Park,Does Anybody Know What Time it is,25 or 624,and more.The other association is of Swamy Vivekananda landing up in a cold, windy,forlorn city and presenting a great speech to a Congress of Religions that opened many American eyes to a different wisdom. This was in the early years of the 20th century.
    Reading your vivid account raises so many thoughts that being puzzled appears to be the easy way out. Family ( have Americans monopolized the arrangement and flogged it to death?), bringing up a wonderfully different human being,being hassled about the whole process, hues of Loneliness,yet so wonderfully positive and earnest.Great.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Yes, you got it, Rudi. Hues of loneliness yet very honest or earnest.... Just telling it like it was.... Thank you for you kind words and for reading...

      Delete
  2. I enjoyed reading and relating to your essay in more ways than one. When my children were small I wished they had the extended family fluff and love I did not get when I was a child, so coiled by nostalgic thoughts I flew grandpa & grandma over the Atlantic ocean to make them a part of my children's life, only to realize that, no party was getting loved or fluffed as I assumed and projected... Listening to my children (they can be darn honest when it's not about them..)I realized that judging my "motherly" qualities I was most of the time misguided by my own experiences and perceptions. My 14 year old daughter summed it all up: "mom don't inflict pain on yourself, stop judging!"

    Please visit my blog and comment, thanks.
    http://lissa-nobodyschild.blogspot.com/

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Thank you, Lisa, appreciate your own prespective. I was just telling it like it was....from mine. Of course I looked at your blog and loved the excerpt about the rooster! Am looking forward to reading more....

      Delete
  3. What a beautiful post and such a wonderful tribute to your adult daughter! I really enjoyed it and am looking forward to reading more -- about your daughter (and now your grandchildren...how exciting!). Thanks for connecting with me over the dementia issue, and let's stay in touch. You work in journalism? For which publication, may I ask?

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Thank you for your lovely comment. You are exacty right -- this is a tribute.... I will stay in touch through your blog and wish you well and admire your wonderful strength!

      Delete
  4. Is it a case of the grass is always greener? Your daughter sounds like she is doing well and the relationship you two have seems to work for you two. Cliche - whatever works or it's all good.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Thank you for reading and for your comment. I am sure you agree we all want for the best for our kids. And I will tell you that is so, even though there are things one simply cannot do for a child because one is alone and has so many other demands and no one to share this responsibility with. The truth is that parenting a child alone, without any extended family or resources, is really hard, and does really put one's child at a disadvantage. Unlike you, I have never known the grass on the other side of the fence. As I said, circumstances were far from ideal, and the only thing we had to go on, even when parenting over the miles, was the strength of our relationship. It's not a case of cliche or that anything goes or whatever works or that it's all good. It was a case of parenting against the odds. It was very difficult, and my daughter simply accepted this situation, while knowing no other; She was a compassionate child, who understood my position, way beyond her years, and was able to nonetheless thrive. This essay is no less than my love poem to her

      Delete
  5. Absolutely beautiful. So heartfelt and poetic and beautiful. Thanks for writing this.

    ReplyDelete
  6. Leslie, what a lovely comment! Poetic, well.... you are right on. This was written for my daughter with emotion as heartfelt as a that of a poem. But I thought I was writng somewhat ruefully, reflecting with much regret about all that I was simply unable to do.... It is indeed an expression of love. Thank you so much Leslie for reading and your perspective and kind comment. Let us stay in touch!

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. You're welcome, Olya. This piece just moved me so much. I'm a mom of two--eight and 10 yrs old--and am raising them in vastly different circumstances. So in no way should be able to relate to all that you've gone through raising your daughter. But the emotions and immediacy and reflection (how both immediacy and reflection are possible?) came through. Yes, the regret is there, but so is survival and thriving and doing the absolute best with the "family of two" that you had. I re-read it three times. It lingers with me. Beautiful.

      Delete
    2. Leslie, I tried to reply to your comment and managed to delete my reply! Here it is again:
      Your response sounds so much like that of a writer and I am interested in the issues you raise. About immediacy and reflection: I used the airport scene as a touchstone for my meditations about my own life. I often shift between past and present, using something that is occurring in present time to reflect upon the past. And yes, My writing is comtemplative. As in my training in the study of European literature, I am often concerned about the larger meaning, or, the meaning of it all. For me, the answer is found in the love and sacrifices one makes for family and in meaningful work that is of service to others. I have always been very interested in "craft." As for emotion, I guess the sadness and regret comes though, which, as you insightfully point out, is born of love. I hope to continue this discussion with you and thank you again for your second most lovely and touching comment.
      I hope to continue this discussion with you, perhaps in another forum.

      Delete
  7. Dear Olya,

    I admire your writing style, the breath of topics from personal to political and everything that could fit between them, combined with the wonderful and masterful use of English language. I think that this could be because I, as a multi-language person, of the same origin from Ukraine and a refugee from the "socialist paradise," as your parents, was not able to master after living in tis country from 1959.

    My preferred essays in your repertoire,so far as I menaged to read them, are "Airport: A Reflection on Single Parenting" and "On Attending a Taras Shevchenko Poetry Slam" to which I can relate as a mother and as Ukrainian. I looking forward to read all of your writings, and I am sure to find many more.

    Olga Verro, Editor of "Voices from The Past" and "Golosa is Proshlogo" by Orest M. Gladky.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Olga,
      Thank you so much for reading and for your kind comments. I am happy that we somehow found each other through this post. As for what you say about my use of the English language, thank you. Like for you, it is my second language though. I am surprised that you picked this piece, as it is not really about my heritage, just about raising my daughter. However, it does have that typical slavic "emotive" expression that I am sure we can both relate to. I do look forward to staying in touch!

      Delete
  8. mamaonetothree.comMarch 27, 2012 at 1:52 PM
    lovely post. you sound a lot like me-- I am so similar with my oldest daughter... sigh. I don't know that I could be any different.

    ReplyDelete









    Olya ThompsonMarch 27, 2012 at 2:07 PM
    Love your blog. So honest and true. The sacrifices you make for your kids, Wendy, are so obvious!










    ReplyDelete

    ReplyDelete